Latest Guantanamo ruling reaffirms American values
Court sends powerful message, upholds rights for detainees.
In baseball, the rule is three strikes and you're out. On Thursday, the Supreme Court called that third strike against the Bush administration and Congress over the system they devised for holding enemy combatants at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
Twice before, the court has rejected the administration's attempts to bar foreigners at Guantanamo from challenging their detentions in regular civilian courts. Thursday's 5-4 decision made it plain that right cannot be suspended, even for those suspected of terrorism. Now it's time for the White House and Congress to accept that call and move on, rather than continue trying to craft new ways to get around the umpire — and the Constitution.
The ruling opens the door to federal courts for about 270 prisoners whose indefinite, years-long detentions have given the nation a black eye throughout much of the world. The gut reaction of many Americans may be that the prisoners are getting better treatment than they deserve. In some cases, perhaps they are. But the ruling also sends a powerful message about U.S. justice.
For all the hoopla over the court's rebuke of administration policies, the ruling simply upheld America's long tradition, known as the right to habeas corpus, that anyone in confinement can go before an impartial judge to challenge that confinement.